Prince William County Board of Supervisors recently unanimously approved a measure aimed at discouraging illegal immigrants from settling in the county. This measure requires the police to check on the immigration status of anyone they detain if there is probable cause to believe the person is undocumented. The Supervisors voted to approve the measure despite the objections of the county's police chief who claims that the measure would diminish cooperation with law enforcement and put further strain on very limited resources.
The immigration discussion is a difficult one and there are no right answers. At some point down the road, I expect the issue to come before the Loudoun County BOS. The challenges are enormous and until we all agree there are no perfect solutions, we will continue to go around in circles. As long as there is an appetite for cheaper sources of labor, and there are people willing to do certain categories of work for less than an average legal resident will be willing to be paid for the same job, this problem would remain.
We can not eat our cake and have it, the illegal immigrants are in plain view, we all can see them - if they are doing the sometimes dangerous work in our communities that we do not want to do, we have no problems - as long as they do not live in our own backyard (NIMBY) thereby increasing the strain on the public services that we use.
The easy and popular view is to propose that all illegal immigrants be deported over a period of time or even immediately, but that is simplistic and impractical. They are here, and again, as difficult as this may sound, the majority of them will remain as long as there are willing employers. I dare say that even our government indirectly hires illegal immigrants through contractors, though I do not have any facts to substantiate this, but I know that contractors often have problems finding workers to pave our roads, clean windows of high rise government buildings, anytime there is a crackdown by Immigration officials.
So what should we do - some of the proposals in the failed senate immigration bill makes sense at the national level, as a matter of urgency, using technology and other means available, immediately secure our northern and southern borders, if necessary use state guards and other appropriate law enforcement agencies, upon payment of a fine - grant a special 5 year visa for these illegal immigrants as long as there is a verifiable US based employer that has paid US taxes for at least 3 years, and the applicant must have no criminal record and be able to speak English. After a 5 year period, the visa recipients can apply for an extension. Also individuals on this visa cannot apply for US citizenship under any circumstances.
At the local level, enforce or enact residential overcrowding and anti-loitering laws, create one or two designated areas for day laborers, and the laborers must register with the county, i.e., fingerprints etc. We need to get these individuals out of the shadows, and let them pay taxes and share the cost of the services they enjoy, though some of them already do.
If you disagree with me, you probably have very good reasons too and I would like to hear them. I understand this is a very sensitive topic and my view as stated above is extremely unpopular. I have read articles such as this, and I do not see solutions, we all know the issues, we need solutions.